The Indiana High School All-Star - Tyler W. Roth MVP Award is given to the player chosen by the media who they feel was the most valuable player for their performance in the All-Star Game. Each team has a player selected/nominated. Then, the media votes from the final 2 players.
2001 Michael Ledo, Fort Wayne Bishop Luers H.S.
2002 Dennis Mitchell, Warren Central H.S.
2003 Jawann Turner, Hammond H.S.
2004 Wally Cirafesi, Munster H.S.
2005 Donald Washington, Franklin Central H.S.
2006 Ben Chappell, Bloomington South H.S.
2007 Eric Watt, South Newton H.S.
2008 Adam Wiese, Perry Meridian H.S.
2009 Skyler Titus, Northwood H.S.
2010 Daniel Wadicka, West Lafayette H.S.
2011 Trey Reese, Indian Creek H.S.
2012 Danny Anthrop, Lafayette Central Catholic
2013 Aaron Daniel, Charlestown
2014 Christian Perry, Southport H.S.